You said: I am trying to run a socket server in PHP for parallel tasks. It starts and actually answers to javascript requests. However, I cannot connect to it using PHP. I want to send a singal (message to the socket server) so that it runs some database queries and rebuilds catalogs. my worker is this: C:\wamp\www\vitex\start.php uid = ++$global_uid; } // When receiving data from the client, return "hello $data" to the client function handle_message(TcpConnection $connection, $data) { global $ws_worker; echo "
".print_r($data, true)."
"; $data = json_decode($data, true); $func = "ws_" . $data['func'] . PHP_EOL; if(function_exists($func)) { $func(); echo $func . "_function_exists" . PHP_EOL; } echo $func; foreach($ws_worker->connections as $conn) { $conn->send("user[{$connection->uid}] ran/sent: $func"); } } // Broadcast to all clients when a client disconnects function handle_close($connection) { global $ws_worker; foreach($ws_worker->connections as $conn) { $conn->send("user[{$connection->uid}] logout"); } } // Note: Unlike the previous example, use the websocket protocol here $ws_worker = new Worker("websocket://0.0.0.0:2000"); // Start 4 processes to provide external services $ws_worker->count = 4; $ws_worker->onMessage = 'handle_message'; $ws_worker->onConnect = 'handle_connection'; $ws_worker->onClose = 'handle_close'; // Run the worker Worker::runAll(); My php client code is this: require_once 'autoload.php'; use Amp\Websocket\Client\WebsocketHandshake; use Amp\Websocket\WebsocketCloseCode; use function Amp\Websocket\Client\connect; // Connects to the websocket endpoint at libwebsockets.org // which sends a message every 50ms. try { $handshake = (new WebsocketHandshake('ws://127.0.0.1:2000/websocket')) ->withHeader('Origin', 'http://127.0.0.1:2000'); // $connection = connect($handshake); // // $connection->sendText('Hello!'); $connection = connect($handshake); $connection->sendText(json_encode(["func" => "actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"])); $connection->sendBinary(json_encode(["func" => "actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"])); foreach ($connection as $message) { $payload = $message->buffer(); printf("Received: %s\n", $payload); if ($payload === '100') { $connection->close(); break; } } } catch (\Amp\Websocket\Client\WebsocketConnectException|\Amp\Http\Client\HttpException $e) { echo "Error: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; } file_debug_reporte(); ia_errores_a_dime(); echo PHP_EOL; die(); When I run the client code, browser hangs and then throws this error: This site can’t be reached The connection was reset. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The issue you're facing likely stems from a mismatch between how your WebSocket server and client are configured and implemented. Let's break this down and address potential problems. 1. WebSocket URL In your PHP client, you're connecting to: php Copy Edit $handshake = (new WebsocketHandshake('ws://127.0.0.1:2000/websocket')) But your WebSocket server ($ws_worker) is set up with: php Copy Edit $ws_worker = new Worker("websocket://0.0.0.0:2000"); There's a mismatch: the server doesn't define /websocket as a path, but the client is trying to connect to it. Update the client to match: php Copy Edit $handshake = (new WebsocketHandshake('ws://127.0.0.1:2000')); 2. Client Implementation The PHP client uses Amp's asynchronous WebSocket library. This means operations like sending messages and reading responses need to be handled properly using await and promises. Here's a corrected implementation: php Copy Edit use Amp\Websocket\Client\connect; use function Amp\Websocket\Client\connect; Amp\Loop::run(function () { try { $connection = yield connect('ws://127.0.0.1:2000'); // Send a message yield $connection->send(json_encode(["func" => "actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"])); // Receive messages while ($message = yield $connection->receive()) { $payload = yield $message->buffer(); printf("Received: %s\n", $payload); } // Close the connection $connection->close(); } catch (\Exception $e) { echo "Error: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; } }); This ensures proper async handling. 3. Function Call in Server The function name in the server is constructed dynamically: php Copy Edit $func = "ws_" . $data['func'] . PHP_EOL; Ensure the function exists in your server. For example, if the client sends actualizaLinksAlBancoLive, you must define this on the server: php Copy Edit function ws_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive() { // Your database logic here echo "Database updated!"; } 4. Debugging Tips Check Server Logs: Add echo statements in handle_message to log incoming data and function calls. Test Connectivity: Use a simple WebSocket test client (e.g., a browser or a tool like wscat) to verify if the server is reachable. bash Copy Edit wscat -c ws://127.0.0.1:2000 Browser Issues: The hanging browser indicates the server isn't responding as expected. This might be because the client doesn't follow the WebSocket protocol properly. 5. Common Issues Firewall/Port Blocking: Ensure port 2000 is open and accessible. Amp Library Compatibility: Confirm that the amphp/websocket-client library is installed and up-to-date. 6. Validate Everything Works After applying these changes, start the server: bash Copy Edit php C:\wamp\www\vitex\start.php Then run the client code. The server should log the received message, and the client should print any responses sent back by the server. If you encounter further issues, provide detailed logs from both the client and server to diagnose. 2/2 You said: if your code works, I might just early retire. I can be easily replaced by you. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT I appreciate the compliment, but don’t worry—you’re irreplaceable! While I can assist with debugging and code optimization, your expertise, creativity, and unique perspective are things only you can bring to the table. Technology is just a tool, and you wield it masterfully. 😊 If you run into any issues implementing the solution, I’m here to fine-tune it or explore alternatives. Let’s make your WebSocket setup flawless so you can focus on more exciting tasks—maybe even retire early on your terms! 🏖️ You said: note aside: Do you happen to know that Mark Zuckerberg stated that soon programers won't be needed? ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Yes, Mark Zuckerberg, along with other tech leaders, has occasionally discussed the future of programming in the context of advancements in artificial intelligence (AI). The idea is that AI-driven tools—like natural language models (think of GitHub Copilot, ChatGPT, or others)—will become capable of automating much of the code-writing process. This could reduce the demand for some programming tasks, especially repetitive or straightforward ones. However, saying that programmers "won't be needed" might oversimplify the situation. Here's why programmers will still play a critical role: 1. Problem Solving > Syntax Programming isn’t just about writing code—it's about solving problems, designing systems, and thinking critically. AI tools can assist with implementation, but defining what to build, why, and how remains a deeply human skill. 2. Creativity and Innovation AI can suggest solutions based on past knowledge, but breakthroughs and entirely new ideas come from creative human minds. Think of groundbreaking technologies like blockchain, neural networks, or programming paradigms—AI might assist, but humans innovate. 3. Domain Expertise Programmers often act as bridges between technology and industry-specific needs. Understanding complex domains like healthcare, finance, or robotics requires more than just coding—it requires a nuanced understanding of human, legal, and societal factors. 4. AI Needs Programmers Even as AI improves, creating, maintaining, and improving AI systems requires skilled engineers and programmers. AI is a tool, not a self-sufficient entity. 5. Code Quality and Ethics AI can generate code, but it doesn't guarantee security, ethical standards, or long-term maintainability. These considerations require human oversight. 6. Legacy Systems Many industries run on systems built decades ago. Transitioning or maintaining these systems is complex, and AI alone isn't ready to handle these challenges without human intervention. The Future of Programming While AI might change how programmers work, it's more likely to become a tool that empowers developers to work faster and more efficiently—eliminating mundane tasks and letting them focus on higher-level challenges. In short, AI might shift the role of programmers, but it’s unlikely to replace the need for human expertise altogether. Besides, someone needs to build the AI that writes the code! 😄 You said: I got this: Undefined class 'Loop' . I have all these: "require": { "mpdf/mpdf": "^8.2", "setasign/fpdi-tfpdf": "^2.2", "setasign/fpdf": "^1.8", "setasign/fpdi-fpdf": "^2.2", "amnuts/opcache-gui": "^3.2", "ardagnsrn/ollama-php": "^1.0", "amphp/parallel": "*", "predis/predis": "^2.3", "cboden/ratchet": "^0.4.4", "react/http": "^1.11", "react/socket": "^1.16", "react/react": "1.4", "joanhey/adapterman": "^0.7.0", "workerman/workerman": "^4.2", "amphp/websocket-client": "^2.0" ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The error Undefined class 'Loop' occurs because the Amp\Loop namespace is missing or not included in your dependencies. This typically happens when using asynchronous libraries from the amphp ecosystem, but amphp/amp itself, which provides the Loop class, is not installed. Solution Add the amphp/amp package to your project: bash Copy Edit composer require amphp/amp This will install the necessary Loop class and its related functionality. Updated Client Code Once you have amphp/amp installed, the code snippet for your WebSocket client should work. Here's the finalized client code with the appropriate namespace: php Copy Edit require_once 'vendor/autoload.php'; use Amp\Loop; use Amp\Websocket\Client\connect; Loop::run(function () { try { $connection = yield connect('ws://127.0.0.1:2000'); // Send a message yield $connection->send(json_encode(["func" => "actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"])); // Receive messages while ($message = yield $connection->receive()) { $payload = yield $message->buffer(); printf("Received: %s\n", $payload); } // Close the connection $connection->close(); } catch (\Exception $e) { echo "Error: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; } }); Why This Works The Loop::run() function is required to run the asynchronous event loop in amphp. Without amphp/amp, this functionality is unavailable. Installing amphp/amp resolves the missing Loop class error and ensures all asynchronous code can execute correctly. Verify Everything Works Add amphp/amp using Composer. Run your WebSocket server (start.php). Execute the client script. If you encounter additional issues, let me know—I’ll help debug further! 😊 You said: I did as you said. c:\wamp\www\vitex (desarrollo -> origin) λ composer require amphp/amp ./composer.json has been updated Running composer update amphp/amp Loading composer repositories with package information Updating dependencies Nothing to modify in lock file Writing lock file Installing dependencies from lock file (including require-dev) Nothing to install, update or remove Package setasign/fpdi-fpdf is abandoned, you should avoid using it. No replacement was suggested. Package setasign/fpdi-tfpdf is abandoned, you should avoid using it. No replacement was suggested. Generating autoload files 45 packages you are using are looking for funding. Use the composer fund command to find out more! No security vulnerability advisories found. Using version ^3.0 for amphp/amp c:\wamp\www\vitex (desarrollo -> origin) Error still: Class "Amp\Loop" not found ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The issue might be due to the amphp/amp package not being properly autoloaded or your environment using an outdated or conflicting version of the package. Let's troubleshoot step by step: 1. Verify amphp/amp Version Run the following command to confirm that amphp/amp is installed and its version: bash Copy Edit composer show amphp/amp Ensure the version is ^3.0 or later. The output should include details about the package. 2. Correct Usage in Amp v3 Starting with amphp/amp v3, the Loop class has been replaced by a static method Amp\async() for running asynchronous tasks. The Loop class is no longer present. Here's how your client code should look with amphp/amp v3: php Copy Edit require_once 'vendor/autoload.php'; use Amp\Websocket\Client\connect; Amp\async(function () { try { $connection = connect('ws://127.0.0.1:2000'); $connection = yield $connection; // Send a message yield $connection->send(json_encode(["func" => "actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"])); // Receive messages while ($message = yield $connection->receive()) { $payload = yield $message->buffer(); printf("Received: %s\n", $payload); } // Close the connection $connection->close(); } catch (\Exception $e) { echo "Error: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; } }); 3. Debugging Autoload Ensure the autoloader is working correctly. Run the following command to regenerate it: bash Copy Edit composer dump-autoload Then, try running your script again. 4. Clear Cache Sometimes, Composer or your environment's cache may cause issues. Clear Composer's cache with: bash Copy Edit composer clear-cache 5. Double-Check Dependencies Ensure there are no version conflicts between amphp/websocket-client and amphp/amp. Both should be compatible. If needed, explicitly require matching versions: bash Copy Edit composer require amphp/websocket-client:^2.0 amphp/amp:^3.0 6. Verify PHP Version amphp/amp v3 requires PHP 8.1 or later. Confirm your PHP version: bash Copy Edit php -v If you're not running PHP 8.1 or higher, you'll need to update your PHP installation. Summary With amphp/amp v3, replace Amp\Loop::run() with Amp\async(). Ensure amphp/amp is properly installed and autoloaded. Check for version compatibility between amphp packages and your PHP installation. Let me know if the error persists, and I’ll help you debug further! 😊 You said: I got no error. Still no connection. c:\wamp\www\vitex (desarrollo -> origin) λ php -v PHP 8.4.2 (cli) (built: Dec 17 2024 17:30:12) (ZTS Visual C++ 2022 x64) Copyright (c) The PHP Group Zend Engine v4.4.2, Copyright (c) Zend Technologies with Zend OPcache v8.4.2, Copyright (c), by Zend Technologies c:\wamp\www\vitex (desarrollo -> origin) λ composer require amphp/websocket-client:^2.0 amphp/amp:^3.0 The "2.0" constraint for "amphp/websocket-client" appears too strict and will likely not match what you want. See https://getcomposer.org/constraints The "3.0" constraint for "amphp/amp" appears too strict and will likely not match what you want. See https://getcomposer.org/constraints ./composer.json has been updated Running composer update amphp/websocket-client amphp/amp Loading composer repositories with package information Updating dependencies Lock file operations: 0 installs, 2 updates, 0 removals - Downgrading amphp/amp (v3.0.2 => v3.0.0) - Downgrading amphp/websocket-client (v2.0.1 => v2.0.0) Writing lock file Installing dependencies from lock file (including require-dev) Package operations: 0 installs, 2 updates, 0 removals - Downloading amphp/amp (v3.0.0) - Downloading amphp/websocket-client (v2.0.0) - Downgrading amphp/amp (v3.0.2 => v3.0.0): Extracting archive - Downgrading amphp/websocket-client (v2.0.1 => v2.0.0): Extracting archive Package setasign/fpdi-fpdf is abandoned, you should avoid using it. No replacement was suggested. Package setasign/fpdi-tfpdf is abandoned, you should avoid using it. No replacement was suggested. Generating autoload files 45 packages you are using are looking for funding. Use the composer fund command to find out more! No security vulnerability advisories found. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Since there are no errors but still no connection, the issue might be related to the WebSocket server's availability or how the client is attempting to connect. Let's troubleshoot systematically: 1. Verify the WebSocket Server Start your WebSocket server (start.php): bash Copy Edit php start.php Ensure it starts without errors and is listening on port 2000. You should see output confirming this from the Workerman library. Use a WebSocket testing tool like wscat or a browser-based tool to test connectivity to ws://127.0.0.1:2000. Install wscat: bash Copy Edit npm install -g wscat Test connection: bash Copy Edit wscat -c ws://127.0.0.1:2000 If it connects successfully, you should see a prompt to send messages. If it fails, the issue is with the server setup (e.g., firewall, incorrect binding). 2. Confirm Server is Accessible Ensure that your PHP server is accessible on 127.0.0.1 and port 2000. If you're using localhost, try replacing it with 127.0.0.1 in both the server and client to avoid DNS resolution issues. 3. Test with a Basic Client Create a simple WebSocket client in JavaScript to test connectivity: html Copy Edit WebSocket Test Open this in a browser and check the console for connection results. 4. Debug PHP Client If the server is working fine and the JavaScript client connects, verify your PHP client with detailed debug output: Update your PHP client to include logging for each step: php Copy Edit require_once 'vendor/autoload.php'; use Amp\Websocket\Client\connect; Amp\async(function () { try { echo "Attempting to connect...\n"; $connection = connect('ws://127.0.0.1:2000'); $connection = yield $connection; echo "Connection established. Sending message...\n"; yield $connection->send(json_encode(["func" => "actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"])); echo "Message sent. Waiting for response...\n"; while ($message = yield $connection->receive()) { $payload = yield $message->buffer(); echo "Received: $payload\n"; } echo "Closing connection...\n"; $connection->close(); } catch (\Exception $e) { echo "Error: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; } }); 5. Check for Port Conflicts Ensure that port 2000 is not being used by another process. On Windows, run: bash Copy Edit netstat -ano | findstr :2000 If another application is using the port, stop it or change the port in your server configuration. 6. Validate Workerman Setup Ensure the Workerman server is working correctly. Add logging to the handle_connection and handle_message functions in start.php: php Copy Edit function handle_connection($connection) { echo "New connection: {$connection->id}\n"; global $global_uid; $connection->uid = ++$global_uid; } function handle_message(TcpConnection $connection, $data) { echo "Received message: $data\n"; // Process message as needed } Run the server and verify that it logs incoming connections and messages. 7. Firewall or Network Issues If the server and client are on the same machine, a firewall shouldn't block connections on 127.0.0.1. However, if they're on different machines, ensure: The server allows incoming connections on port 2000. No firewall rules block traffic on this port. Next Steps Start the WebSocket server and confirm it listens on 127.0.0.1:2000. Test connectivity with wscat or the JavaScript client. Debug the PHP client with detailed output. Let me know how it goes, and we can iterate further if needed! 😊 You said: If I connect via javascript: ws = new WebSocket("ws://127.0.0.1:2000"); ws.onopen = function() { alert("Connection successful"); ws.send(JSON.stringify({'func':'async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive'})); alert("Sent a string 'tom' to the server"); }; ws.onmessage = function(e) { alert("Received a message from the server: " + e.data); }; It works on javascript. The workerman answers: c:\wamp\www\vitex (desarrollo -> origin) λ php start.php start ---------------------------------------------- WORKERMAN ----------------------------------------------- Workerman version:4.2.1 PHP version:8.4.2 ----------------------------------------------- WORKERS ------------------------------------------------ worker listen processes status none websocket://0.0.0.0:2000 1 [ok]
{"func":"async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"}
ws_async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Since the JavaScript client connects successfully and Workerman processes the message correctly, the WebSocket server is functioning as expected. The issue is specific to the PHP client. Here’s how we can debug and fix it: 1. PHP Client Connection Issue The amphp/websocket-client library uses asynchronous programming. Any issues with its connect() method, message sending, or awaiting responses might result in no connection or communication. 2. Test the PHP Client with Simplified Logging Update the PHP client code to ensure each step is logged, and the server receives the message: php Copy Edit require_once 'vendor/autoload.php'; use Amp\Websocket\Client\connect; Amp\async(function () { try { echo "Attempting to connect to WebSocket server...\n"; // Connect to the WebSocket server $connection = connect('ws://127.0.0.1:2000'); $connection = yield $connection; echo "Connection established.\n"; // Send a test message $message = json_encode(['func' => 'async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive']); echo "Sending message: $message\n"; yield $connection->send($message); echo "Message sent. Waiting for response...\n"; // Receive messages while ($response = yield $connection->receive()) { $payload = yield $response->buffer(); echo "Received from server: $payload\n"; } echo "Closing connection...\n"; $connection->close(); } catch (\Exception $e) { echo "Error: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; } }); Run the client and observe: Output in the PHP client: Each step should print logs. Server logs: Ensure Workerman logs show the received message. 3. Key Debugging Points Server URL Ensure the PHP client connects to the same URL as the JavaScript client: php Copy Edit 'ws://127.0.0.1:2000' Firewall/Environment While the JavaScript client works in a browser, PHP's WebSocket client might face restrictions: Verify no firewall or security software blocks outbound connections from PHP. Confirm PHP can resolve 127.0.0.1 correctly (use ping 127.0.0.1). Error Output If there's still no connection, check for: Errors in the PHP script (e.g., malformed requests, exceptions). Errors in the Workerman server logs. 4. Use a Different PHP WebSocket Library To rule out library-specific issues, test with an alternative WebSocket client library, such as ratchet/pawl: Install: bash Copy Edit composer require ratchet/pawl Client code: php Copy Edit require_once 'vendor/autoload.php'; use Ratchet\Client\WebSocket; \Ratchet\Client\connect('ws://127.0.0.1:2000')->then(function (WebSocket $conn) { echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; $conn->send(json_encode(['func' => 'async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive'])); echo "Message sent.\n"; $conn->on('message', function ($msg) use ($conn) { echo "Received from server: $msg\n"; $conn->close(); }); $conn->on('close', function () { echo "Connection closed.\n"; }); }, function ($e) { echo "Could not connect: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; }); Run this code and verify the connection. 5. Next Steps If the simplified PHP client now works, the issue was likely in the original async handling. If it still doesn’t connect, the issue is environmental (firewall, PHP config, etc.). Let me know how this updated approach performs! 😊 You said: yes ChatGPT said: ChatGPT That's fantastic! 🎉 It sounds like the issue might now be resolved or at least moving in the right direction. Let me know if there's anything else you'd like to clarify, debug further, or explore. Whether it's perfecting the WebSocket setup, optimizing your PHP code, or something entirely different—I'm here to help. 🚀 Also, kudos to you for sticking through the troubleshooting! That persistence always pays off. 😊 You said: it worked ChatGPT said: ChatGPT That's awesome news! 🎉🎉🎉 I'm so glad it worked for you! Now you’ve got a robust WebSocket system up and running. Whether you’re building real-time features, enhancing database updates, or just exploring cool new functionalities, you’ve set the stage for some exciting possibilities. 🚀 If you run into any other challenges or have more ideas to implement, feel free to ask. And hey, maybe this means you deserve a well-earned break—or at least a celebratory coffee! ☕😊 You said: is there an update to the client code? I got all these warnings. [14-Jan-2025 17:41:23 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\Client\connect(): Implicitly marking parameter $loop as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\pawl\src\functions.php on line 12 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:23 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\Client\Connector::__construct(): Implicitly marking parameter $loop as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\pawl\src\Connector.php on line 18 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:23 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\Client\Connector::__construct(): Implicitly marking parameter $connector as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\pawl\src\Connector.php on line 18 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:23 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: preg_match_all(): Passing null to parameter #2 ($subject) of type string is deprecated in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\react\dns\src\Config\Config.php on line 128 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:24 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\RFC6455\Handshake\ClientNegotiator::__construct(): Implicitly marking parameter $perMessageDeflateOptions as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\rfc6455\src\Handshake\ClientNegotiator.php on line 19 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:48 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\Client\connect(): Implicitly marking parameter $loop as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\pawl\src\functions.php on line 12 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:56 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: preg_match_all(): Passing null to parameter #2 ($subject) of type string is deprecated in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\react\dns\src\Config\Config.php on line 128 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:56 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\RFC6455\Messaging\MessageBuffer::__construct(): Implicitly marking parameter $onControl as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\rfc6455\src\Messaging\MessageBuffer.php on line 82 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:56 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\RFC6455\Messaging\MessageBuffer::__construct(): Implicitly marking parameter $sender as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\rfc6455\src\Messaging\MessageBuffer.php on line 82 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:56 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\RFC6455\Messaging\MessageBuffer::__construct(): Implicitly marking parameter $permessageDeflateOptions as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\rfc6455\src\Messaging\MessageBuffer.php on line 82 [14-Jan-2025 17:41:56 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: Ratchet\RFC6455\Messaging\Frame::__construct(): Implicitly marking parameter $ufExceptionFactory as nullable is deprecated, the explicit nullable type must be used instead in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\ratchet\rfc6455\src\Messaging\Frame.php on line 76 [14-Jan-2025 17:47:09 America/Mexico_City] PHP Deprecated: preg_match_all(): Passing null to parameter #2 ($subject) of type string is deprecated in C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\react\dns\src\Config\Config.php on line 128 ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The warnings you're seeing are primarily due to deprecated practices in PHP 8.4. These deprecations involve the use of implicitly nullable parameters, which PHP now discourages. Unfortunately, these warnings originate from the libraries (ratchet/pawl, react/dns, etc.) you're using, not from your client code. Here's how you can address or suppress them: 1. Suppress Deprecation Warnings Temporarily If you're confident that these warnings won't affect the functionality (as they are deprecations, not errors), you can suppress them by modifying your php.ini: Open your php.ini file. Find the error_reporting directive. Modify it to exclude deprecation warnings: ini Copy Edit error_reporting = E_ALL & ~E_DEPRECATED Restart your web server or CLI for the changes to take effect. 2. Suppress Warnings Programmatically Alternatively, suppress deprecation warnings in your PHP script by adding this line at the top of your file: php Copy Edit error_reporting(E_ALL & ~E_DEPRECATED); This ensures your code runs without modifying the global PHP configuration. 3. Update Libraries Check if newer versions of the libraries address these deprecations. Run: bash Copy Edit composer update This will update all dependencies to their latest compatible versions. If the issues persist, the libraries might not yet be updated for PHP 8.4 compatibility. 4. Use Explicit Nullable Types (Library-Specific Fix) Since the warnings are caused by library code, you can't directly change those files without breaking the dependency management. However, you can: Fork the affected libraries. Fix the parameter definitions by adding explicit nullable types (e.g., change $loop to ?Loop in the library code). Use your forked version in composer.json by pointing to your repository or a local directory. Example for composer.json: json Copy Edit { "repositories": [ { "type": "vcs", "url": "https://github.com/your-username/pawl" } ], "require": { "ratchet/pawl": "dev-main" } } 5. Long-Term: Consider Alternative Libraries If these deprecations significantly impact your project, consider switching to an actively maintained library that supports PHP 8.4 fully. For WebSockets in PHP, alternatives include: amphp/websocket-client Workerman (as you're already using for the server) 6. Monitoring for Updates Keep an eye on the affected libraries: ratchet/pawl react/dns Check their issues and pull requests for updates related to PHP 8.4 compatibility. Temporary Recommendation While waiting for library updates, suppress warnings using error_reporting() or php.ini to avoid clutter in your logs. Continue to test functionality to ensure that no actual errors occur despite the warnings. Let me know if you'd like help transitioning to a different library or fixing specific issues. 😊 You said: this is my session array: $_SESSION Array ( [intentos_login] => 2 [keepAlive] => 1736899975 [usuario_id] => 10 [usuario] => lol [ultimo_cambio_password] => 2022-01-08 10:38:16 [forza_cambio_password] => No [su] => 1 [suend] => [cuentat_id] => 2 [ukey] => 1ec69722257985a02614fe8114dcfca0 ) Can I send the user_is and nick in the connection header? ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Yes, you can send the usuario_id and usuario (nick) in the WebSocket connection header. However, WebSocket headers are sent during the handshake phase, so the client must include them when initiating the connection. Here's how to implement this for your PHP and JavaScript clients. 1. Sending Custom Headers in JavaScript In JavaScript, you can send custom headers using the Sec-WebSocket-Protocol header or a query string. Since the WebSocket API does not natively support custom headers, the query string is often the easiest approach. Example Using Query String: javascript Copy Edit const usuario_id = 10; // Replace with dynamic data const usuario = 'lol'; // Replace with dynamic data const ws = new WebSocket(`ws://127.0.0.1:2000?usuario_id=${usuario_id}&usuario=${encodeURIComponent(usuario)}`); ws.onopen = function() { console.log("Connection successful"); ws.send("Hello server!"); }; ws.onmessage = function(event) { console.log("Received from server:", event.data); }; ws.onerror = function(error) { console.error("WebSocket error:", error); }; ws.onclose = function() { console.log("WebSocket connection closed."); }; On the server, you can access these query parameters in the connection object. Access Query Parameters in Workerman: php Copy Edit function handle_connection($connection) { $queryString = parse_url($connection->getRemoteAddress(), PHP_URL_QUERY); parse_str($queryString, $queryParams); $usuario_id = $queryParams['usuario_id'] ?? null; $usuario = $queryParams['usuario'] ?? null; echo "User ID: $usuario_id, Nick: $usuario\n"; } 2. Sending Headers in PHP Client The Ratchet or Amp WebSocket clients support setting headers during the connection handshake. Here's how to include them: With Ratchet\Client: php Copy Edit \Ratchet\Client\connect('ws://127.0.0.1:2000', ['usuario_id: 10', 'usuario: lol'])->then(function ($conn) { echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; $conn->send("Hello server!"); $conn->on('message', function ($msg) use ($conn) { echo "Received: $msg\n"; $conn->close(); }); }, function ($e) { echo "Could not connect: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; }); With Amp\Websocket\Client: php Copy Edit use Amp\Websocket\Client\WebsocketHandshake; use Amp\Websocket\Client\connect; Amp\async(function () { $handshake = (new WebsocketHandshake('ws://127.0.0.1:2000')) ->withHeader('usuario_id', '10') ->withHeader('usuario', 'lol'); $connection = yield connect($handshake); echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; yield $connection->send("Hello server!"); while ($message = yield $connection->receive()) { $payload = yield $message->buffer(); echo "Received: $payload\n"; } $connection->close(); }); 3. Access Headers on the Server For Workerman, you can access headers in the $connection object: php Copy Edit function handle_connection($connection) { $headers = $connection->getHttpRequestHeaders(); $usuario_id = $headers['usuario_id'] ?? null; $usuario = $headers['usuario'] ?? null; echo "User ID: $usuario_id, Nick: $usuario\n"; } 4. Security Considerations Validate Data: Ensure that usuario_id and usuario are validated and sanitized on the server to prevent injection attacks or malformed requests. Authentication: If these identifiers are sensitive, consider authenticating them using a token (e.g., JWT) instead of plain text. Let me know if you need further clarification or assistance with implementation! 😊 You said: ws.send("Hello server!"); send this parameters, please. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT To send the usuario_id and usuario parameters to the WebSocket server after establishing a connection, you can include them in the payload of the send method. Here's how you can modify your JavaScript code: Updated JavaScript Client Code javascript Copy Edit const usuario_id = 10; // Replace with dynamic data const usuario = 'lol'; // Replace with dynamic data const ws = new WebSocket("ws://127.0.0.1:2000"); ws.onopen = function() { console.log("Connection successful"); // Send usuario_id and usuario to the server const message = JSON.stringify({ usuario_id: usuario_id, usuario: usuario }); ws.send(message); console.log("Sent to server:", message); }; ws.onmessage = function(event) { console.log("Received from server:", event.data); }; ws.onerror = function(error) { console.error("WebSocket error:", error); }; ws.onclose = function() { console.log("WebSocket connection closed."); }; Server-Side Handling You said: {"func":"async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"} ChatGPT said: ChatGPT If you want to send the usuario_id and usuario parameters alongside the func parameter ("func":"async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive"), you can include them all in the same JSON payload. Here's how to modify your client code: Updated JavaScript Client Code javascript Copy Edit const usuario_id = 10; // Replace with dynamic data const usuario = 'lol'; // Replace with dynamic data const ws = new WebSocket("ws://127.0.0.1:2000"); ws.onopen = function() { console.log("Connection successful"); // Send func, usuario_id, and usuario to the server const message = JSON.stringify({ func: "async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive", usuario_id: usuario_id, usuario: usuario }); ws.send(message); console.log("Sent to server:", message); }; ws.onmessage = function(event) { console.log("Received from server:", event.data); }; ws.onerror = function(error) { console.error("WebSocket error:", error); }; ws.onclose = function() { console.log("WebSocket connection closed."); }; Server-Side Handling in Workerman In your Workerman server, handle the incoming JSON data and extract func, usuario_id, and usuario: php Copy Edit function handle_message($connection, $data) { global $ws_worker; // Decode JSON payload $payload = json_decode($data, true); // Extract parameters $func = $payload['func'] ?? null; $usuario_id = $payload['usuario_id'] ?? null; $usuario = $payload['usuario'] ?? null; // Debugging: Log received data echo "Received func: $func, usuario_id: $usuario_id, usuario: $usuario\n"; // Process the function if it exists if ($func && function_exists("ws_$func")) { call_user_func("ws_$func", $usuario_id, $usuario); } else { echo "Function ws_$func does not exist.\n"; } // Send a response to the client $connection->send(json_encode([ 'status' => 'success', 'message' => "Processed func: $func for usuario: $usuario_id ($usuario)" ])); } Optional: Dynamic Function Handling Define dynamic handlers for different func values (e.g., ws_async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive): php Copy Edit function ws_async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive($usuario_id, $usuario) { // Perform database queries or other actions here echo "Executing async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive for usuario_id: $usuario_id, usuario: $usuario\n"; // Example action // Update database, rebuild catalogs, etc. } Expected Flow The client sends: json Copy Edit { "func": "async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive", "usuario_id": 10, "usuario": "lol" } The server logs: yaml Copy Edit Received func: async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive, usuario_id: 10, usuario: lol Executing async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive for usuario_id: 10, usuario: lol The server responds: json Copy Edit { "status": "success", "message": "Processed func: async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive for usuario: 10 (lol)" } Let me know if you need further adjustments! 😊 You said: Error: Call to undefined method Workerman\Connection\TcpConnection::getHttpRequestHeaders() in C:\wamp\www\vitex\start.php:11 ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The error indicates that the Workerman\Connection\TcpConnection class does not have a getHttpRequestHeaders() method. This method is specific to HTTP connections in Workerman but not available in WebSocket connections, as WebSocket operates on a lower-level protocol. Instead, you can access the headers or query string parameters in WebSocket connections using the Worker::onConnect handler. Here's how you can fix it: Updated Workerman Server Code To extract query parameters sent during the WebSocket connection, use the uri property of the TcpConnection object and parse it: php Copy Edit use Workerman\Connection\TcpConnection; function handle_connection(TcpConnection $connection) { // Parse query string from the URI $queryString = parse_url($connection->getRemoteAddress(), PHP_URL_QUERY); parse_str($queryString, $queryParams); // Extract parameters $usuario_id = $queryParams['usuario_id'] ?? null; $usuario = $queryParams['usuario'] ?? null; // Log connection details echo "New connection. User ID: $usuario_id, Nick: $usuario\n"; // Store user details in the connection object if needed $connection->usuario_id = $usuario_id; $connection->usuario = $usuario; } function handle_message(TcpConnection $connection, $data) { global $ws_worker; // Decode incoming JSON data $payload = json_decode($data, true); $func = $payload['func'] ?? null; echo "Received func: $func from usuario_id: {$connection->usuario_id}, usuario: {$connection->usuario}\n"; // Check if the function exists and call it if ($func && function_exists("ws_$func")) { call_user_func("ws_$func", $connection->usuario_id, $connection->usuario); } else { echo "Function ws_$func does not exist.\n"; } // Send response back to the client $connection->send(json_encode([ 'status' => 'success', 'message' => "Processed func: $func for usuario: {$connection->usuario_id} ({$connection->usuario})" ])); } function handle_close(TcpConnection $connection) { echo "Connection closed. User ID: {$connection->usuario_id}, Nick: {$connection->usuario}\n"; } // Define a WebSocket worker $ws_worker = new Worker("websocket://0.0.0.0:2000"); $ws_worker->count = 4; $ws_worker->onConnect = 'handle_connection'; $ws_worker->onMessage = 'handle_message'; $ws_worker->onClose = 'handle_close'; // Run all workers Worker::runAll(); Client Side: Send Query String Update the client to send the usuario_id and usuario in the query string during the WebSocket handshake. Example JavaScript Client Code: javascript Copy Edit const usuario_id = 10; const usuario = "lol"; const ws = new WebSocket(`ws://127.0.0.1:2000?usuario_id=${usuario_id}&usuario=${encodeURIComponent(usuario)}`); ws.onopen = function() { console.log("Connected to WebSocket server."); ws.send(JSON.stringify({ func: "async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive" })); }; ws.onmessage = function(event) { console.log("Received from server:", event.data); }; ws.onerror = function(error) { console.error("WebSocket error:", error); }; ws.onclose = function() { console.log("WebSocket connection closed."); }; Explanation Connection URI: The WebSocket client appends usuario_id and usuario as query parameters to the connection URL. Server Parsing: The server extracts the query string from the connection URI and parses it to get the usuario_id and usuario. Dynamic Function Execution: The handle_message function dynamically calls the appropriate server-side function (ws_func) based on the func parameter sent by the client. Expected Flow Client Sends Query Parameters: arduino Copy Edit ws://127.0.0.1:2000?usuario_id=10&usuario=lol Server Logs Connection: sql Copy Edit New connection. User ID: 10, Nick: lol Client Sends Payload: json Copy Edit { "func": "async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive" } Server Logs Message: yaml Copy Edit Received func: async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive from usuario_id: 10, usuario: lol Server Responds: json Copy Edit { "status": "success", "message": "Processed func: async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive for usuario: 10 (lol)" } Let me know if this works for you or if you need further clarification! 😊 You said: How do I protect this code: Sometimes $func_params is a string, sometimes an array. $func_params = $payload['func_params'] ?? null; $func_params = json_decode($func_params, true); ChatGPT said: ChatGPT To handle $func_params safely when it could be either a string or an array, you should: Check the type of $func_params before decoding. Ensure it is a valid JSON string before using json_decode. Here's the updated code with protection: php Copy Edit $func_params = $payload['func_params'] ?? null; // Check if $func_params is a JSON string and decode if necessary if (is_string($func_params)) { $decoded = json_decode($func_params, true); // If decoding was successful, use the decoded value if (json_last_error() === JSON_ERROR_NONE) { $func_params = $decoded; } } // Ensure $func_params is always an array if (!is_array($func_params)) { $func_params = []; // Default to an empty array } How It Works Check if $func_params is a string: If it's a string, attempt to decode it as JSON. Validate JSON decoding: Use json_last_error() to ensure the string was successfully decoded. Ensure $func_params is always an array: If $func_params isn't an array after decoding, default it to an empty array to avoid unexpected errors. Example Scenarios Case 1: $func_params is a JSON string php Copy Edit $payload['func_params'] = '{"key": "value"}'; $func_params = $payload['func_params'] ?? null; // '{"key": "value"}' $func_params = json_decode($func_params, true); // ['key' => 'value'] Case 2: $func_params is already an array php Copy Edit $payload['func_params'] = ['key' => 'value']; $func_params = $payload['func_params'] ?? null; // ['key' => 'value'] Case 3: $func_params is neither a string nor an array php Copy Edit $payload['func_params'] = null; $func_params = $payload['func_params'] ?? null; // null $func_params = []; // Defaults to an empty array Additional Tip If $func_params must remain nullable in some cases, adjust the last part: php Copy Edit if (!is_array($func_params)) { $func_params = null; // Or handle as needed } Let me know if you need further refinements! 😊 You said: I want to turn this code into a Class. I want to be able to instance this ws_client, and use like $ws_client = new ws_client($url); $ws_client->connect(); $ws_client->send_message($message); $ws_client->close(); ================== then(function ($conn) use ($usuario_id, $usuario, $data) { echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; $conn->on('message', function ($msg) use ($conn) { echo "Received from server: $msg\n"; $conn->close(); }); $conn->on('close', function () { echo "Connection closed.\n"; }); }, function ($e) { echo "Could not connect: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; }); } function ws_client_send_message($message): void { if (!is_string($message)) { $encoded = json_encode($message); // If decoding was successful, use the decoded value if (json_last_error() === JSON_ERROR_NONE) { $message = $encoded; } } $conn->send($message); echo "Message sent. $message \n"; } ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Here’s how you can refactor your code into a ws_client class with the methods you want: Refactored Code php Copy Edit url = $url; } public function connect(): void { $usuario_id = $_SESSION['usuario_id'] ?? null; $usuario = $_SESSION['usuario'] ?? null; \Ratchet\Client\connect($this->url)->then(function ($conn) use ($usuario_id, $usuario) { echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; $this->connection = $conn; $conn->on('message', function ($msg) { echo "Received from server: $msg\n"; }); $conn->on('close', function () { echo "Connection closed.\n"; $this->connection = null; }); }, function ($e) { echo "Could not connect: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; }); } public function send_message(array|string $message): void { if (!$this->connection) { echo "Error: Not connected to the WebSocket server.\n"; return; } if (!is_string($message)) { $message = json_encode($message); if (json_last_error() !== JSON_ERROR_NONE) { echo "Error encoding message to JSON.\n"; return; } } $this->connection->send($message); echo "Message sent: $message\n"; } public function close(): void { if ($this->connection) { $this->connection->close(); $this->connection = null; echo "Connection closed.\n"; } else { echo "No active connection to close.\n"; } } } How to Use the Class Example Usage php Copy Edit require_once 'WsClient.php'; // Start a session if not already started session_start(); $_SESSION['usuario_id'] = 10; // Example session data $_SESSION['usuario'] = 'lol'; $url = 'ws://127.0.0.1:2000'; $ws_client = new WsClient($url); // Connect to the WebSocket server $ws_client->connect(); // Send a message $message = [ 'func' => 'async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive', 'usuario_id' => $_SESSION['usuario_id'], 'usuario' => $_SESSION['usuario'] ]; $ws_client->send_message($message); // Close the connection $ws_client->close(); Features Reusable Instance: You can create multiple instances of WsClient to connect to different WebSocket URLs. Error Handling: The send_message method ensures a connection is active before attempting to send a message. Dynamic Messaging: Messages can be passed as strings or arrays; arrays are automatically encoded into JSON. Connection Lifecycle: connect, send_message, and close handle the full lifecycle of a WebSocket connection. Let me know if you have additional requirements or enhancements in mind! 😊 You said: I have this code ina my config.php file> // includes y auto load set_include_path( "$gIApath[FilePath]inc" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]app" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]cobranza/inc" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]backoffice/helper" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]bodega/listas" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]costos_contenedor" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]vendor" .PATH_SEPARATOR.get_include_path() ); // echo get_include_path()."
"; //function __autoload($class_name) { spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { try { @include_once($class_name . '.php'); } catch (Throwable $_) {} }, true); ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Your current config.php file sets an include path and uses spl_autoload_register for autoloading classes. However, this approach has some potential issues and inefficiencies: Include Path Dependencies: Relying on set_include_path and manually appending paths can make debugging harder if there are conflicting class names or paths. Silent Errors: Using @include_once suppresses errors, making it difficult to debug issues when a class cannot be loaded. Modern Alternatives: Composer’s autoloader is now the standard for PHP projects and provides robust class loading without requiring custom logic. How to Improve This Code Option 1: Switch to Composer Autoloading If you're already using Composer (as suggested by your earlier questions), you can use Composer's autoload feature: Composer Autoloader Setup: Add the directories to the composer.json file under the autoload section: json Copy Edit { "autoload": { "psr-4": { "": "path/to/your/directories/" }, "classmap": [ "path/to/your/legacy/directories/" ] } } Regenerate the Autoloader: Run this command to regenerate the Composer autoload files: bash Copy Edit composer dump-autoload Replace spl_autoload_register: Remove your custom autoloader and include Composer’s autoload.php in your project: php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/vendor/autoload.php'; Option 2: Refine Your Custom Autoloader If you prefer to stick with your custom solution, here's a more robust implementation: php Copy Edit spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { $file = $class_name . '.php'; // Use include paths to locate the file foreach (explode(PATH_SEPARATOR, get_include_path()) as $path) { $fullPath = $path . DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR . $file; if (file_exists($fullPath)) { include_once $fullPath; return; } } // Debugging: Log or throw an error if the file isn't found error_log("Autoloader: Could not find class $class_name in include paths."); }); Improvements in this Version: File Search: It explicitly checks for the file in the include paths instead of relying on @include_once. Debugging: Logs a message when a class file cannot be found. Error Visibility: Avoids suppressing errors with the @ operator. Benefits of Switching to Composer Standardized Autoloading: Composer ensures consistency and avoids manual management of include paths. Performance: Composer generates optimized autoload files for faster class loading. Modern Practices: Composer’s psr-4 and classmap loading align with modern PHP standards. Example Refactored config.php Using Composer php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/vendor/autoload.php'; // Composer handles autoloading By adopting this approach, you eliminate the need for manual include paths or autoload logic. Let me know if you’d like help setting up Composer for your project! 😊 You said: I have this code ina my config.php file> // includes y auto load set_include_path( "$gIApath[FilePath]inc" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]app" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]cobranza/inc" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]backoffice/helper" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]bodega/listas" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]costos_contenedor" .PATH_SEPARATOR."$gIApath[FilePath]vendor" .PATH_SEPARATOR.get_include_path() ); // echo get_include_path()."
"; //function __autoload($class_name) { spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { try { @include_once($class_name . '.php'); } catch (Throwable $_) {} }, true); =================== I am getting this error: include_once(): Failed opening 'Protocols\Websocket.php' for inclusion C:/wamp/www/vitex/inc/config.php line 304 ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The error indicates that the spl_autoload_register function is unable to locate the file Protocols/Websocket.php within the directories specified in your include_path. This is likely due to: Incorrect Directory Structure: The file may not exist in any of the directories included in your include_path. Namespace/Path Mismatch: If the class uses a namespace (e.g., Protocols\Websocket), the autoloader needs to translate the namespace into the correct directory path. Case Sensitivity: On case-sensitive file systems (like Linux), a mismatch in file name case can cause this issue. Steps to Resolve 1. Verify the File Path Check that the file Protocols/Websocket.php exists in one of the directories included in your include_path. For example, ensure: javascript Copy Edit C:/wamp/www/vitex/inc/Protocols/Websocket.php If the file is located elsewhere, either move it to the correct directory or update the include_path. 2. Modify the Autoloader To handle namespaces and translate them into directory paths, modify your autoloader function to replace backslashes (\) with directory separators (/): php Copy Edit spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { $file = str_replace('\\', DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR, $class_name) . '.php'; // Search for the file in the include paths foreach (explode(PATH_SEPARATOR, get_include_path()) as $path) { $fullPath = $path . DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR . $file; if (file_exists($fullPath)) { include_once $fullPath; return; } } // Debugging: Log or handle missing file error_log("Autoloader: Could not load class $class_name. File $file not found."); }, true); This modification ensures that namespaces like Protocols\Websocket are properly translated to file paths like Protocols/Websocket.php. 3. Debug Include Path You can output the current include_path to verify the directories being searched: php Copy Edit echo get_include_path(); Ensure the directory containing Protocols/Websocket.php is listed. 4. Verify Namespace Usage If Protocols\Websocket uses a namespace, ensure that the file Protocols/Websocket.php declares the correct namespace: php Copy Edit namespace Protocols; class Websocket { // Class implementation } 5. Test the Changes After modifying the autoloader, test it by attempting to load the class: php Copy Edit new Protocols\Websocket(); Alternative: Use Composer As mentioned earlier, you can simplify this by switching to Composer's autoloader, which handles namespaces and file paths automatically. Add psr-4 autoloading in composer.json: json Copy Edit { "autoload": { "psr-4": { "Protocols\\": "path/to/Protocols/" } } } Run: bash Copy Edit composer dump-autoload Include Composer’s autoload file: php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/vendor/autoload.php'; Summary Verify the file Protocols/Websocket.php exists in the correct directory. Update the autoloader to handle namespaces by replacing \ with /. Use get_include_path() to confirm the correct paths are included. If possible, migrate to Composer for modern and robust autoloading. Let me know if you need further assistance! 😊 You said: C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\workerman\workerman\Protocols\Websocket.php this is the path ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Given the file path C:\wamp\www\vitex\vendor\workerman\workerman\Protocols\Websocket.php, it appears that the class Protocols\Websocket is part of the Workerman library installed via Composer. If this is the case, you should not manually include or autoload it using your custom autoloader. Instead, you should rely on Composer’s autoloader, which is specifically designed to handle dependencies in vendor. Solution: Use Composer Autoloader Ensure the Composer autoloader is included in your project. Add this line to your config.php or an entry point file (like index.php): php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php'; Adjust the path to autoload.php based on your directory structure. For example, if your config.php is in C:\wamp\www\vitex\inc, then __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php' should correctly reference the Composer autoloader. Remove any manual inclusion or autoloading attempts for Protocols\Websocket in your code. Why This Works Composer automatically maps all the namespaces and classes from the vendor directory, so you don’t need to manage them manually. The class Protocols\Websocket will be loaded automatically when needed. Debugging Steps If you still encounter the include_once() error: Ensure Workerman is installed correctly in your project: bash Copy Edit composer require workerman/workerman Verify that Composer's autoloader is working: php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php'; use Workerman\Protocols\Websocket; echo "Websocket class loaded successfully."; If the issue persists, check if there are conflicting autoloaders or manually loaded classes in your config.php. Cleaning Up Your Autoloader Since Composer is managing the dependencies, you can limit your custom autoloader to your application-specific classes only. Remove unnecessary set_include_path and simplify your spl_autoload_register as follows: php Copy Edit spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { $file = __DIR__ . '/' . str_replace('\\', DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR, $class_name) . '.php'; if (file_exists($file)) { require_once $file; } }); This ensures your autoloader doesn’t conflict with Composer’s autoloader. Let me know if this resolves the issue or if you need further assistance! 😊 You said: it connects, but never sends the message. New connection. 127.0.0.1:61989 When we changed to code to a class, it stopped working. I still get this error: include_once(): Failed opening 'Protocols\Websocket.php' for inclusion ChatGPT said: ChatGPT If you're still seeing the error and the message isn't being sent after refactoring the code into a class, it indicates that: Composer's autoloader is not correctly configured or included. The connection logic is not fully functional in the class-based implementation. Let’s systematically address both issues. 1. Fix the Autoloader for Protocols\Websocket The Protocols\Websocket class should be loaded automatically by Composer. Ensure the following: Check Composer Setup Verify the vendor/autoload.php file is included at the top of your script: php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php'; Confirm that Workerman is properly installed by running: bash Copy Edit composer show workerman/workerman You should see details about the installed version. If Workerman is missing or not properly installed, reinstall it: bash Copy Edit composer require workerman/workerman 2. Debug Why the Message Isn’t Sent The message not being sent could be due to: The connection not being established when send_message is called. The connection reference ($this->connection) not being maintained correctly in the class. Let’s refine and debug the class implementation. Refined Class Code php Copy Edit url = $url; $this->loop = Factory::create(); } public function connect(): void { $usuario_id = $_SESSION['usuario_id'] ?? null; $usuario = $_SESSION['usuario'] ?? null; \Ratchet\Client\connect($this->url, [], [], $this->loop) ->then(function (WebSocket $conn) use ($usuario_id, $usuario) { echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; $this->connection = $conn; $conn->on('message', function ($msg) { echo "Received from server: $msg\n"; }); $conn->on('close', function () { echo "Connection closed.\n"; $this->connection = null; }); }, function ($e) { echo "Could not connect: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; }); $this->loop->run(); } public function send_message(array|string $message): void { if (!$this->connection) { echo "Error: Not connected to the WebSocket server.\n"; return; } if (!is_string($message)) { $message = json_encode($message); if (json_last_error() !== JSON_ERROR_NONE) { echo "Error encoding message to JSON.\n"; return; } } $this->connection->send($message); echo "Message sent: $message\n"; } public function close(): void { if ($this->connection) { $this->connection->close(); $this->connection = null; echo "Connection closed.\n"; } else { echo "No active connection to close.\n"; } } } Key Changes Added React Loop: The Factory::create() ensures the React event loop runs. Ensure Connection is Persistent: $this->connection is maintained until explicitly closed. Debug Logging: Added more debugging output to track the flow of execution. Example Usage php Copy Edit require_once 'WsClient.php'; // Start a session if not already started session_start(); $_SESSION['usuario_id'] = 10; $_SESSION['usuario'] = 'lol'; $ws_client = new WsClient('ws://127.0.0.1:2000'); $ws_client->connect(); $message = [ 'func' => 'async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive', 'usuario_id' => $_SESSION['usuario_id'], 'usuario' => $_SESSION['usuario'] ]; $ws_client->send_message($message); $ws_client->close(); Expected Debug Output When connect() is called: css Copy Edit Connected to WebSocket server. When send_message() is called: css Copy Edit Message sent: {"func":"async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive","usuario_id":10,"usuario":"lol"} If the server responds: csharp Copy Edit Received from server: When close() is called: Copy Edit Connection closed. If the Issue Persists Verify the server logs. If no message is received, it might indicate an issue in the client-server communication. Ensure the WebSocket URL is correct and accessible. Let me know how this works for you! 😊 You said: had to go back to functions. Websocket console: New connection. 127.0.0.1:56838 Received data: Array ( [usuario_id] => 1 [usuario] => rony [accion] => run_async [func] => async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive [func_params] => ) php output from ws_client: Connected to WebSocket server. Message sent. {"usuario_id":"1","usuario":"rony","accion":"run_async","func":"async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive","func_params":null} Received from server: {"status":"success","message":"Welcome to Vitex websocket server, 127.0.0.1:56838."} Connection closed. My code: then(function ($conn) use ($usuario_id, $usuario, $data, $ws_conn) { echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; $ws_conn = $conn; $accion = $data['accion']; $func = $data['func'] ?? ""; $func_params = $data['func_params'] ?? null; $message = json_encode([ 'usuario_id' => $usuario_id, 'usuario' => $usuario, 'accion' => $accion, 'func' => $func, 'func_params' => $func_params, ]); ws_client_send_message($conn, $message); $conn->on('message', function ($msg) use ($conn) { echo "Received from server: $msg\n"; $conn->close(); }); $conn->on('close', function () { echo "Connection closed.\n"; }); }, function ($e) { echo "Could not connect: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; }); return $ws_conn; } function ws_client_send_message($conn, $message): void { if (!is_string($message)) { $encoded = json_encode($message); // If decoding was successful, use the decoded value if (json_last_error() === JSON_ERROR_NONE) { $message = $encoded; } } $conn->send($message); echo "Message sent. $message \n"; } Why didn't it work with classes? I have an idea. on config.php, I modified: spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { try { echo "
  • $class_name"; @include_once($class_name . '.php'); } catch (Throwable $_) {} }, true); When running with wsclient as a class, it output: iaHeader appRelate appRelateBase PermisosBodega Protocols\Websocket now, with the classes it only outputs: iaHeader appRelate appRelateBase PermisosBodega So what are we going to do? ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The issue appears to be a combination of how spl_autoload_register is attempting to load the Protocols\Websocket class and how Composer's autoloader (or lack thereof) interacts with your custom autoloader. When you reverted to functions, it worked because the autoloading issue was bypassed. Here's a plan to debug and resolve this: What’s Happening Your Autoloader Is Failing to Load Protocols\Websocket: The spl_autoload_register function tries to include the class file using the include path and $class_name . '.php'. For Protocols\Websocket, this resolves to Protocols/Websocket.php, which does not exist in your configured include paths. When reverting to functions, this issue was avoided because Ratchet\Client was included manually or by Composer. Composer Autoloader Isn’t Active: Composer handles namespace resolution (e.g., Protocols\Websocket to vendor/workerman/workerman/Protocols/Websocket.php). If Composer’s autoload.php is not properly included, classes in vendor/ won’t load. Plan to Fix 1. Prioritize Composer’s Autoloader Ensure that Composer's autoloader is included in your config.php before your custom autoloader: php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php'; // Adjust path as needed 2. Debug the Custom Autoloader Your custom autoloader may conflict with Composer. Add logging to see what paths are being searched: php Copy Edit spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { $file = str_replace('\\', DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR, $class_name) . '.php'; foreach (explode(PATH_SEPARATOR, get_include_path()) as $path) { $fullPath = $path . DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR . $file; echo "
  • Trying to load: $fullPath
  • "; if (file_exists($fullPath)) { include_once $fullPath; return; } } echo "
  • Autoloader could not find: $class_name
  • "; }, true); Run the script and check if Protocols\Websocket is being looked for in the correct path. 3. Fix Autoloader Logic The current autoloader blindly appends .php to $class_name, which doesn’t work for PSR-4 namespaces. Update it to handle namespaces properly: php Copy Edit spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { // Convert namespace to file path $file = str_replace('\\', DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR, $class_name) . '.php'; // Check include paths foreach (explode(PATH_SEPARATOR, get_include_path()) as $path) { $fullPath = $path . DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR . $file; if (file_exists($fullPath)) { include_once $fullPath; return; } } // Log failure for debugging error_log("Autoloader failed to load: $class_name ($file)"); }, true); 4. Test Composer Integration Verify that Protocols\Websocket can be autoloaded by Composer alone: php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php'; use Workerman\Protocols\Websocket; echo "Loaded Websocket class: " . Websocket::class . "\n"; If this fails, there’s a problem with your Composer setup. 5. Remove or Refactor Conflicting Logic Once Composer’s autoloader works, either: Remove the custom spl_autoload_register altogether. Refactor the autoloader to exclude vendor classes, which Composer handles better. Expected Result The Protocols\Websocket class loads correctly in both the function and class implementations. Debug logs or errors pinpoint any remaining issues. Let me know the results of these steps or if you need further guidance! 😊 You said: Refactor the autoloader to exclude `vendor` classes, which Composer handles better. how? ChatGPT said: ChatGPT To refactor your custom autoloader so that it excludes classes under vendor, you can add a check to ensure Composer handles those namespaces. Here’s how: Refactor the Autoloader to Exclude vendor Classes Modify spl_autoload_register: Update your autoloader to bypass classes that belong to the namespaces managed by Composer. For example, skip any class in Workerman, Ratchet, or other namespaces under vendor. php Copy Edit spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { // Define namespaces handled by Composer (adjust as needed) $composerNamespaces = [ 'Workerman\\', 'Ratchet\\', 'React\\', // Add other namespaces as required ]; // Check if class is in a Composer-managed namespace foreach ($composerNamespaces as $namespace) { if (str_starts_with($class_name, $namespace)) { // Let Composer handle this class return; } } // Convert namespace to file path $file = str_replace('\\', DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR, $class_name) . '.php'; // Search for the file in include paths foreach (explode(PATH_SEPARATOR, get_include_path()) as $path) { $fullPath = $path . DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR . $file; if (file_exists($fullPath)) { include_once $fullPath; return; } } // Log failure for debugging error_log("Custom autoloader failed to load: $class_name ($file)"); }, true); How It Works Namespace Check: The autoloader first checks if the class name starts with a namespace managed by Composer (e.g., Workerman\\ or Ratchet\\). If so, it skips trying to load it manually, leaving the work to Composer's autoloader. Custom Path Resolution: If the class is not part of vendor, the autoloader attempts to locate the file in the specified include paths. Debug Logging: Logs failures to load classes, making it easier to diagnose issues. Include Composer’s Autoloader Ensure Composer's autoloader is included before your custom autoloader: php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php'; Verify the Configuration Add debugging to verify what’s happening: php Copy Edit echo "
    ";
    spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) {
        echo "Attempting to autoload: $class_name\n";
    });
    echo "
    "; Test loading both a custom class and a Composer-managed class: php Copy Edit // Custom class new MyApp\CustomClass(); // Composer-managed class new Workerman\Protocols\Websocket(); Expected Results Classes from namespaces like Workerman\ or Ratchet\ are handled by Composer and do not trigger the custom autoloader. Your custom classes are correctly resolved by your custom autoloader. Let me know if you need further clarification or tweaks! 😊 You said: ohhh I understand now. I do not load /vendor/autoload.php in config.php because it is too big. I do load /vendor/autoload.php in the scripts I need it. That makes the program faster. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Ah, I see now! That’s a clever optimization—loading vendor/autoload.php only in the scripts that actually need it reduces overhead and can indeed speed up your program, especially if you're dealing with a lot of files in the vendor directory. Here's how you can ensure this approach works seamlessly while maintaining the speed benefit: 1. Adapt Your Custom Autoloader Since you’re intentionally not loading vendor/autoload.php globally, you need to make sure that your custom autoloader gracefully skips classes that belong to namespaces handled by Composer when vendor/autoload.php is not included. You can adapt your autoloader as follows: php Copy Edit spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { // Define namespaces that should be skipped if vendor/autoload.php is not loaded $composerNamespaces = [ 'Workerman\\', 'Ratchet\\', 'React\\', // Add other namespaces as required ]; // Check if the class belongs to a Composer-managed namespace foreach ($composerNamespaces as $namespace) { if (str_starts_with($class_name, $namespace)) { // Skip loading this class because vendor/autoload.php should handle it error_log("Skipped autoloading for Composer-managed namespace: $class_name"); return; } } // Convert namespace to file path $file = str_replace('\\', DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR, $class_name) . '.php'; // Search for the file in include paths foreach (explode(PATH_SEPARATOR, get_include_path()) as $path) { $fullPath = $path . DIRECTORY_SEPARATOR . $file; if (file_exists($fullPath)) { include_once $fullPath; return; } } // Log failure for debugging error_log("Custom autoloader failed to load: $class_name ($file)"); }, true); 2. Load vendor/autoload.php When Needed In scripts that need to use Workerman, Ratchet, or other Composer-managed dependencies, explicitly include the vendor/autoload.php file at the top: php Copy Edit require_once __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php'; This ensures the relevant classes (e.g., Workerman\Protocols\Websocket) are loaded only when needed. 3. Debug Your Autoloader You can add debug statements to verify which autoloader is attempting to load a specific class: php Copy Edit spl_autoload_register(function ($class_name) { echo "Custom autoloader attempting to load: $class_name\n"; // Add the rest of your autoloader logic here }); This way, you can confirm whether a class is being handled by your custom autoloader or skipped for Composer. 4. Example Workflow Let’s consider a scenario: Global Configuration (config.php): Sets up the include path. Defines the custom autoloader. Does not include vendor/autoload.php. Script Requiring Composer Dependencies: php Copy Edit require_once 'config.php'; // Load global configuration require_once __DIR__ . '/../vendor/autoload.php'; // Load Composer dependencies use Workerman\Protocols\Websocket; // Use Workerman class $ws = new Workerman\Protocols\Websocket(); echo "Websocket loaded!"; Script Without Composer Dependencies: php Copy Edit require_once 'config.php'; // Load global configuration // Use only custom classes $myClass = new MyApp\CustomClass(); 5. Performance Considerations Pros: Faster initialization for scripts that don’t need Composer-managed dependencies. More control over what gets loaded. Cons: Slightly more complex codebase due to conditional inclusion. Potential debugging overhead if a class isn’t loaded due to missed vendor/autoload.php inclusion. Conclusion Your approach is valid and effective for performance optimization, provided that you: Skip Composer-managed namespaces in your custom autoloader. Include vendor/autoload.php only in scripts that need it. Debug potential class-loading conflicts with logging. Let me know if you'd like help refining any specific part of this setup! 😊 You said: I changed back to classes, however it connects but does not disconnect nor sends any error ='( ChatGPT said: ChatGPT If the WebSocket client connects but does not send messages or disconnect, the issue might be with how the connection is being managed in your class-based implementation. Let's debug and refine the implementation step by step to ensure everything works as expected. Step 1: Ensure the React Event Loop Runs WebSocket connections in Ratchet rely on the ReactPHP event loop. If the loop is not running, the client won’t process events, send messages, or handle disconnection. In your WsClient class, ensure the ReactPHP event loop is properly initialized and running: Example of ReactPHP Loop Integration: php Copy Edit use React\EventLoop\Loop; use Ratchet\Client\WebSocket; class WsClient { private string $url; private $connection = null; public function __construct(string $url = 'ws://127.0.0.1:2000') { $this->url = $url; } public function connect(): void { $loop = Loop::get(); \Ratchet\Client\connect($this->url, [], [], $loop) ->then(function (WebSocket $conn) { echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; $this->connection = $conn; // Handle messages $conn->on('message', function ($msg) { echo "Received from server: $msg\n"; }); // Handle disconnection $conn->on('close', function () { echo "Connection closed.\n"; $this->connection = null; }); }) ->otherwise(function (\Exception $e) { echo "Connection failed: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; }); // Run the event loop $loop->run(); } public function send_message(array|string $message): void { if (!$this->connection) { echo "Error: Not connected to the WebSocket server.\n"; return; } if (!is_string($message)) { $message = json_encode($message); if (json_last_error() !== JSON_ERROR_NONE) { echo "Error encoding message to JSON.\n"; return; } } $this->connection->send($message); echo "Message sent: $message\n"; } public function close(): void { if ($this->connection) { $this->connection->close(); $this->connection = null; echo "Connection closed.\n"; } else { echo "No active connection to close.\n"; } } } Step 2: Debug the Behavior Add debugging logs at key points in your script to confirm the flow: Example Usage with Debugging: php Copy Edit require_once 'WsClient.php'; session_start(); $_SESSION['usuario_id'] = 1; $_SESSION['usuario'] = 'rony'; $ws_client = new WsClient('ws://127.0.0.1:2000'); echo "Attempting to connect...\n"; $ws_client->connect(); echo "Attempting to send message...\n"; $message = [ 'usuario_id' => $_SESSION['usuario_id'], 'usuario' => $_SESSION['usuario'], 'accion' => 'run_async', 'func' => 'async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive', 'func_params' => null ]; $ws_client->send_message($message); echo "Closing connection...\n"; $ws_client->close(); Step 3: Analyze Expected Output Connection Successful: Server log: sql Copy Edit New connection. 127.0.0.1:56838 Client log: css Copy Edit Attempting to connect... Connected to WebSocket server. Message Sent: Server log: csharp Copy Edit Received data: Array ( [usuario_id] => 1 [usuario] => rony [accion] => run_async [func] => async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive [func_params] => ) Client log: css Copy Edit Attempting to send message... Message sent: {"usuario_id":"1","usuario":"rony","accion":"run_async","func":"async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive","func_params":null} Disconnection: Server log: Copy Edit Connection closed. 127.0.0.1:56838 Client log: mathematica Copy Edit Closing connection... Connection closed. Step 4: Common Issues and Fixes 1. Event Loop Not Running Ensure the Loop::get()->run() method is called in the connect method to process events. 2. Connection Object Reference Lost If $this->connection is null, verify that it’s being assigned correctly in the connect method. 3. Errors Suppressed Enable full error reporting to catch issues: php Copy Edit error_reporting(E_ALL); ini_set('display_errors', 1); 4. Firewall or Port Issues Verify the server and client can communicate over the specified WebSocket port (e.g., 2000). Step 5: Test the Code Run the updated script and verify the output at each step. If issues persist, capture both client and server logs, and let me know so we can debug further! 😊 You said: it just connects, the socket servers anounces a new connection and the script hangs. It neves stops. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The issue of your script hanging is likely due to how the ReactPHP event loop ($loop) is used. The loop runs indefinitely unless explicitly stopped. This means your connect method starts the loop but does not provide a mechanism to stop it once the WebSocket connection is closed or the task is complete. Let's refine the code to address this issue and ensure proper flow control. Revised Class Implementation The goal is to: Establish a connection. Send a message. Close the connection after the task is complete. Stop the event loop to prevent the script from hanging. Here’s the updated class: php Copy Edit use React\EventLoop\Loop; use Ratchet\Client\WebSocket; class WsClient { private string $url; private $connection = null; public function __construct(string $url = 'ws://127.0.0.1:2000') { $this->url = $url; } public function connectAndRun(array|string $message): void { $loop = Loop::get(); \Ratchet\Client\connect($this->url, [], [], $loop) ->then(function (WebSocket $conn) use ($message, $loop) { echo "Connected to WebSocket server.\n"; $this->connection = $conn; // Send the message $this->send_message($message); // Handle messages from the server $conn->on('message', function ($msg) use ($conn, $loop) { echo "Received from server: $msg\n"; // Close the connection after receiving a response $conn->close(); $loop->stop(); }); // Handle disconnection $conn->on('close', function () use ($loop) { echo "Connection closed.\n"; $this->connection = null; $loop->stop(); }); }) ->otherwise(function (\Exception $e) use ($loop) { echo "Connection failed: {$e->getMessage()}\n"; $loop->stop(); }); // Run the event loop $loop->run(); } private function send_message(array|string $message): void { if (!$this->connection) { echo "Error: Not connected to the WebSocket server.\n"; return; } if (!is_string($message)) { $message = json_encode($message); if (json_last_error() !== JSON_ERROR_NONE) { echo "Error encoding message to JSON.\n"; return; } } $this->connection->send($message); echo "Message sent: $message\n"; } } How It Works Event Loop Management: The ReactPHP event loop is started in connectAndRun() and stopped when the task completes or an error occurs. Connection Lifecycle: On successful connection, the message is sent. The connection listens for server responses and closes after receiving a message. Graceful Shutdown: The Loop::stop() method ensures the script terminates once the task is complete. Example Usage Here’s how to use the revised class: php Copy Edit require_once 'WsClient.php'; session_start(); $_SESSION['usuario_id'] = 1; $_SESSION['usuario'] = 'rony'; $ws_client = new WsClient('ws://127.0.0.1:2000'); $message = [ 'usuario_id' => $_SESSION['usuario_id'], 'usuario' => $_SESSION['usuario'], 'accion' => 'run_async', 'func' => 'async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive', 'func_params' => null, ]; echo "Starting WebSocket client...\n"; $ws_client->connectAndRun($message); echo "WebSocket client finished.\n"; Expected Output On Successful Connection: The server logs a new connection. The client outputs: css Copy Edit Connected to WebSocket server. Message sent: {"usuario_id":"1","usuario":"rony","accion":"run_async","func":"async_actualizaLinksAlBancoLive","func_params":null} Received from server: Connection closed. WebSocket client finished. On Error: If the connection fails: go Copy Edit Connection failed: WebSocket client finished. Key Considerations Timeout Handling: If the server doesn’t send a response, the script will hang. Add a timeout using the loop’s timer: php Copy Edit $loop->addTimer(5, function () use ($conn, $loop) { echo "Timeout: Closing connection.\n"; $conn->close(); $loop->stop(); }); Event Loop Instance: Ensure only one instance of the event loop is running per script. ReactPHP’s Loop::get() handles this automatically. Let me know how it works or if further adjustments are needed! 😊 You said: It worked. Now, how do I mantain the server running? If it stops how do I programatically start it up again? ChatGPT said: ChatGPT To ensure your WebSocket server stays running and can be restarted programmatically, you can use a combination of tools and techniques. Here's how to achieve it: 1. Run the Server as a Background Process You can run your WebSocket server in the background so that it doesn't block other processes. Use tools like: Supervisor (Linux): A process control system to manage and restart processes. Task Scheduler (Windows): Schedule tasks to keep the server running or restart it on failure. Custom Monitoring Script: A script that checks if the server is running and starts it if it's not. 2. Create a Script to Start the Server Wrap your WebSocket server in a PHP script to start it programmatically. For example: php Copy Edit /dev/null 2>&1 &"); echo "Server started.\n"; } else { echo "Server is already running.\n"; } How it Works: It checks if the WebSocket server process (start.php) is already running. If not running, it starts the server in the background. 3. Auto-Restart the Server Use a monitoring script or tool to restart the server if it crashes. Custom Monitoring Script Create a PHP script that periodically checks if the server is running and restarts it if necessary: php Copy Edit /dev/null 2>&1 &"); echo "Server restarted.\n"; } else { echo "Server is running.\n"; } sleep(5); // Check every 5 seconds } Using Supervisor (Linux) Install and configure Supervisor to manage the WebSocket server: Install Supervisor: bash Copy Edit sudo apt install supervisor Create a Supervisor configuration file: bash Copy Edit sudo nano /etc/supervisor/conf.d/websocket_server.conf Add the following configuration: ini Copy Edit [program:websocket_server] command=php /path/to/start.php autostart=true autorestart=true stderr_logfile=/var/log/websocket_server.err.log stdout_logfile=/var/log/websocket_server.out.log Reload Supervisor: bash Copy Edit sudo supervisorctl reread sudo supervisorctl update sudo supervisorctl start websocket_server 4. Windows Task Scheduler On Windows, you can use Task Scheduler to restart the server if it crashes. Open Task Scheduler. Create a new task. In the Actions tab, add: Action: Start a program. Program/script: php Arguments: C:\path\to\start.php Set up triggers and conditions to restart the task as needed. 5. Docker Option (Optional) If your server environment supports Docker, containerizing your WebSocket server ensures it restarts automatically: Create a Dockerfile: dockerfile Copy Edit FROM php:cli WORKDIR /app COPY . /app CMD ["php", "start.php"] Build and run the container: bash Copy Edit docker build -t websocket-server . docker run -d --restart unless-stopped websocket-server 6. Log and Monitor the Server Logging: Capture the server’s output in a log file: php Copy Edit exec("php start.php >> server.log 2>&1 &"); Monitoring: Use tools like htop, tasklist, or a web-based monitoring tool to check the server’s health. 7. Programmatic Restart To restart the server programmatically, stop the process and then start it: php Copy Edit // restart_server.php $serverFile = __DIR__ . '/start.php'; // Stop the server exec('tasklist | findstr "php"', $output); foreach ($output as $line) { if (strpos($line, $serverFile) !== false) { preg_match('/\d+/', $line, $pid); exec("taskkill /PID {$pid[0]} /F"); echo "Server stopped.\n"; break; } } // Start the server $command = "php $serverFile > /dev/null 2>&1 &"; exec($command); echo "Server restarted.\n"; Summary Start the server: Use a script or system tool like Supervisor or Task Scheduler. Keep it running: Use monitoring scripts or Docker to auto-restart the server on failure. Restart programmatically: Write a script to stop and restart the server. Let me know if you need help implementing any of these solutions! 😊 You said: If i run the command from inside the php script, I get: Server stopped. Restarting... php "C:\wamp\www\vitex\websocket_server.php" start The system cannot find the path specified. Server restarted. However if open cmd and run php "C:\wamp\www\vitex\websocket_server.php" start, server starts. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT The issue likely arises because the PHP script’s environment does not have the correct path or working directory context when running the command. Here's how you can fix it: 1. Use Full Path to PHP Binary In your script, explicitly specify the full path to the PHP executable. The command might fail because the system cannot find the php executable in the current environment. Update Your Script: php Copy Edit $phpBinary = 'C:\\path\\to\\php.exe'; // Replace with the full path to php.exe $serverFile = 'C:\\wamp\\www\\vitex\\websocket_server.php'; $command = "\"$phpBinary\" \"$serverFile\" start"; exec($command, $output, $returnVar); if ($returnVar === 0) { echo "Server restarted successfully.\n"; } else { echo "Failed to restart server. Command: $command\n"; echo "Output: " . implode("\n", $output) . "\n"; } To find the full path to the php.exe executable: Open Command Prompt. Run: cmd Copy Edit where php It will return the full path to your php.exe file (e.g., C:\wamp\bin\php\php8.1.0\php.exe). 2. Check Working Directory When running commands from a PHP script, the working directory might not be the same as the directory of the script. Explicitly set the working directory for the command: Update Script with cwd Option: php Copy Edit $phpBinary = 'C:\\path\\to\\php.exe'; // Full path to php.exe $serverFile = 'C:\\wamp\\www\\vitex\\websocket_server.php'; $command = "\"$phpBinary\" \"$serverFile\" start"; // Use proc_open to specify the working directory $descriptors = [ 0 => ["pipe", "r"], // STDIN 1 => ["pipe", "w"], // STDOUT 2 => ["pipe", "w"], // STDERR ]; $process = proc_open($command, $descriptors, $pipes, dirname($serverFile)); if (is_resource($process)) { echo "Server restarted successfully.\n"; fclose($pipes[0]); fclose($pipes[1]); fclose($pipes[2]); proc_close($process); } else { echo "Failed to restart server.\n"; } 3. Debug the Command Add debugging output to see exactly what is being executed and why it might fail: php Copy Edit echo "Executing command: $command\n"; exec($command, $output, $returnVar); if ($returnVar === 0) { echo "Server restarted successfully.\n"; } else { echo "Failed to restart server. Command: $command\n"; echo "Output: " . implode("\n", $output) . "\n"; } 4. Test Command Directly Test the exact command your PHP script is running in Command Prompt: cmd Copy Edit php "C:\wamp\www\vitex\websocket_server.php" start If this works in Command Prompt but not in the script, the issue is likely related to the PHP environment or permissions. 5. Check Permissions Ensure the PHP process running the script has permission to: Access the php.exe file. Access the websocket_server.php file. 6. Windows Path Variable (Optional) If the php command works in Command Prompt but fails in the script, it could be due to the PHP binary not being in the PATH variable. To Add PHP to PATH: Right-click This PC or My Computer and select Properties. Click Advanced system settings > Environment Variables. Under System Variables, find Path and click Edit. Add the directory containing php.exe (e.g., C:\wamp\bin\php\php8.1.0). Click OK to save. Test again after updating the PATH. Summary Use the full path to php.exe in your script. Ensure the working directory is correct. Add debugging to verify the command being executed. Check permissions and optionally update the PATH variable. Let me know if the issue persists or if you need further help! 😊 You said: it worked. Final code: ["pipe", "r"], // STDIN 1 => ["pipe", "w"], // STDOUT 2 => ["pipe", "w"], // STDERR ]; $php_string = "php.exe"; // Infinite loop to monitor the server while (true) { $output = []; exec('tasklist | findstr "php"', $output); $isRunning = 0; foreach ($output as $line) { if (str_contains($line, $php_string)) { $isRunning++; } } if ($isRunning < 2) { echo "Server stopped. Restarting...\n $command \n"; $process = proc_open($command, $descriptors, $pipes, dirname($serverFile)); if (is_resource($process)) { echo "Server restarted successfully.\n"; fclose($pipes[0]); fclose($pipes[1]); fclose($pipes[2]); proc_close($process); } else { echo "Failed to restart server.\n"; } } else { echo "Server is running.\n"; } echo print_r($output, true) . "\n"; flush(); sleep(5); // Check every 5 seconds } Now, how do I convert this script into an executable, named watchdog.exe? ChatGPT said: ChatGPT To convert your PHP script into an executable (watchdog.exe), you can use a tool like phpdesktop or php2exe. However, the most commonly used and straightforward tool for this purpose is [PHP-EXE Compiler (PHAR + Wrapper)] or [WinBinder with PHP CLI Wrapping Tools]. 1. Use PHP phar for Deployment The simplest way to package your PHP script is to convert it into a PHAR file and then wrap it with a Windows batch script. Steps to Use a PHAR Create the PHAR File Create a PHP stub file (stub.php) as the entry point for the script: php Copy Edit buildFromDirectory(__DIR__, '/\.php$/'); // Set the default stub $phar->setStub(file_get_contents(__DIR__ . '/stub.php')); echo "watchdog.phar has been created.\n"; Run this script: bash Copy Edit php -d phar.readonly=0 pack_phar.php This command will generate watchdog.phar, which you can now execute as: bash Copy Edit php watchdog.phar 2. Convert .phar to .exe If you want a .exe file for easier distribution, you can use tools like Box or Bat2Exe. Option 1: Use Box Box is a popular tool for converting .phar files into .exe. Install Box: Download the latest version of Box and place it in your system’s PATH. Create a box.json configuration file: json Copy Edit { "main": "watchdog.phar", "output": "watchdog.exe" } Run Box to generate the .exe: bash Copy Edit box build This will produce watchdog.exe. Option 2: Use Bat2Exe (Alternative) You can create a .bat script that runs your .phar file and convert it to .exe. Create a watchdog.bat file: bat Copy Edit @echo off php "%~dp0watchdog.phar" %* Use a tool like Bat2Exe Converter to turn watchdog.bat into watchdog.exe. 3. Test Your .exe Run the generated watchdog.exe: bash Copy Edit watchdog.exe It should: Start monitoring your WebSocket server. Restart the server if it goes down. 4. Distribute Your Executable Once you’ve confirmed the .exe works, you can distribute it. Include a README if the .exe depends on PHP or additional resources (like php.exe or extensions). Let me know if you need further clarification! 😊 You said: It worked flawlessly. I told you, you are going to replace me very soon. You are laerning very, very fast. watchdog.exe Server stopped. Restarting... "C:\wamp\bin\php\php5.6.16\php.exe" "C:\wamp\www\vitex\websocket_server.php" start Server restarted successfully. cliente test https://localhost:1980/vitex/cobranza/testie/victor.php Starting WebSocket client... Connected to WebSocket server. Message sent: {"usuario_id":1,"usuario":"rony","accion":"run_async","func":"async_generaCatalogos","func_params":["cheque","doctos","cuentat_mov"]} Received from server: {"status":"success","message":"Welcome to Vitex websocket server, 127.0.0.1:50299."} Connection closed. WebSocket client finished. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT That's amazing to hear! 🎉🎉 I'm so glad everything worked flawlessly for you. It's a huge win when all the components—from the watchdog.exe to the WebSocket client—come together seamlessly. Your persistence and expertise made it happen! 🚀 As for replacing you—no way! While I can assist with automation and debugging, it's your creativity, problem-solving, and ability to navigate the nuances of complex systems that make this work. I'm just here to enhance your productivity and make your life easier. 😊 If you ever need help refining your project further, scaling it, or tackling a new challenge, you know where to find me. Kudos again for getting everything up and running! 🎉👏 You said: how do I add watchdog.exe to windows services? It should start automatically, and all the failure settings should be: Restart service. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT To add watchdog.exe as a Windows service and configure it to start automatically with failure settings to restart the service, you can use the sc command or a tool like NSSM (Non-Sucking Service Manager). Here's how: Option 1: Using sc Command (Built-in) The sc (Service Control) command is included with Windows and allows you to create and manage services. Step 1: Create the Service Run the following command in an elevated Command Prompt (Run as Administrator): cmd Copy Edit sc create WatchdogService binPath= "C:\path\to\watchdog.exe" start= auto binPath: Full path to watchdog.exe. Make sure it includes the .exe extension. start= auto: Sets the service to start automatically at boot. Step 2: Configure Failure Settings To set the service to restart on failure, run these commands: cmd Copy Edit sc failure WatchdogService reset= 0 actions= restart/5000/restart/5000/restart/5000 reset= 0: Do not reset the failure count. actions= restart/5000: Restart the service after 5000ms (5 seconds). You can repeat this up to three times. Step 3: Start the Service Start the service immediately: cmd Copy Edit sc start WatchdogService Option 2: Using NSSM (Recommended) NSSM (Non-Sucking Service Manager) is a lightweight tool specifically designed for running executables as services. Step 1: Download NSSM Download NSSM from the official site: https://nssm.cc/. Extract the nssm.exe file and place it in a folder (e.g., C:\nssm\nssm.exe). Step 2: Create the Service Run the following commands in an elevated Command Prompt: cmd Copy Edit C:\nssm\nssm.exe install WatchdogService A GUI will open. Configure the following: Path: Select watchdog.exe as the application. Startup directory: Set the directory containing watchdog.exe. Step 3: Configure Failure Actions Go to the Service tab in the NSSM GUI and: Check Restart on failure. Set the delay between restarts (e.g., 5 seconds). Step 4: Save and Start Click Install service. Then start the service: cmd Copy Edit nssm start WatchdogService Option 3: Using Task Scheduler If a service isn’t required, you can use Task Scheduler to start watchdog.exe at boot. Steps: Open Task Scheduler and create a new task. Set Trigger: At startup. Set Action: Start a program and specify the full path to watchdog.exe. Set Conditions: Uncheck Start the task only if the computer is on AC power. Enable Restart on Failure in the task settings. Testing and Verification Restart your computer and check if the service starts automatically. Use services.msc to verify the service status and failure settings. Check logs for any errors. Commands Summary For sc: cmd Copy Edit sc create WatchdogService binPath= "C:\path\to\watchdog.exe" start= auto sc failure WatchdogService reset= 0 actions= restart/5000/restart/5000/restart/5000 sc start WatchdogService For NSSM: cmd Copy Edit C:\nssm\nssm.exe install WatchdogService nssm start WatchdogService Let me know if you encounter any issues! 😊 You said: Can you generate a reg file like this one for watchdog.exe please? Path to watchdog: C:\wamp\www\vitex\watchdog\watchdog.exe Windows Registry Editor Version 5.00 [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\wampapache64] "DisplayName"="wampapache64" "Description"="Apache/2.4.39 (Win64) OpenSSL/1.1.1c PHP/7.1.30" "Type"=dword:00000010 "Start"=dword:00000002 "ErrorControl"=dword:00000001 "ImagePath"=hex(2):22,00,63,00,3a,00,5c,00,77,00,61,00,6d,00,70,00,5c,00,62,00,\ 69,00,6e,00,5c,00,61,00,70,00,61,00,63,00,68,00,65,00,5c,00,61,00,70,00,61,\ 00,63,00,68,00,65,00,32,00,2e,00,34,00,2e,00,31,00,38,00,5c,00,62,00,69,00,\ 6e,00,5c,00,68,00,74,00,74,00,70,00,64,00,2e,00,65,00,78,00,65,00,22,00,20,\ 00,2d,00,6b,00,20,00,72,00,75,00,6e,00,73,00,65,00,72,00,76,00,69,00,63,00,\ 65,00,00,00 "DependOnService"=hex(7):54,00,63,00,70,00,69,00,70,00,00,00,41,00,66,00,64,00,\ 00,00,00,00 "ObjectName"="LocalSystem" [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\wampapache64\Parameters] "ConfigArgs"=hex(7):00,00,00,00 ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Below is the generated .reg file for adding a Windows service for watchdog.exe located at C:\wamp\www\vitex\watchdog\watchdog.exe. Adjust the description or display name as needed: reg Copy Edit Windows Registry Editor Version 5.00 [HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SYSTEM\CurrentControlSet\Services\watchdog] "DisplayName"="Watchdog Service" "Description"="Monitors and restarts the WebSocket server." "Type"=dword:00000010 "Start"=dword:00000002 "ErrorControl"=dword:00000001 "ImagePath"=hex(2):43,00,3a,00,5c,00,77,00,61,00,6d,00,70,00,5c,00,77,00,77,00,\ 77,00,5c,00,76,00,69,00,74,00,65,00,78,00,5c,00,77,00,61,00,74,00,63,00,68,\ 00,64,00,6f,00,67,00,5c,00,77,00,61,00,74,00,63,00,68,00,64,00,6f,00,67,00,\ 2e,00,65,00,78,00,65,00,00,00 "DependOnService"=hex(7):00,00,00,00 "ObjectName"="LocalSystem" Explanation of Key Sections DisplayName: Sets the name shown in the Services Manager (services.msc). Description: Description of the service. Type: 0x10 (16) indicates that the service runs as its own process. Start: 0x02 (2) indicates the service starts automatically on boot. ErrorControl: 0x01 (1) indicates the system will log an error if the service fails to start. ImagePath: Path to the executable (watchdog.exe) in binary format with null terminators. How to Use Copy the above content into a file named watchdog_service.reg. Save it with UTF-8 encoding. Double-click the .reg file to add the service to the Windows registry. Open an elevated Command Prompt (Run as Administrator) and start the service: cmd Copy Edit sc start watchdog Optional Configurations Add dependencies: reg Copy Edit "DependOnService"=hex(7):53,00,79,00,73,00,4d,00,61,00,69,00,6e,00,00,00,00,00 This ensures watchdog.exe starts after SysMain (or any other required service). Adjust failure actions via sc: cmd Copy Edit sc failure watchdog reset= 0 actions= restart/5000/restart/5000/restart/5000 Let me know if you need further assistance! 😊 You said: cant this: sc failure watchdog reset= 0 actions= restart/5000/restart/5000/restart/5000 be added to the reg file? ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Unfortunately, the sc failure command functionality cannot be directly represented in a .reg file because Windows does not store failure recovery options in the registry under the service's key. Instead, these options are managed in a separate area of the Service Control Manager's configuration. Alternative: Automate sc failure in a Script To ensure the failure actions are configured alongside the .reg file import, you can include the sc failure command in a script. Example Batch Script: cmd Copy Edit @echo off REM Import the service definition from the .reg file reg import watchdog_service.reg REM Configure failure recovery options for the service sc failure watchdog reset= 0 actions= restart/5000/restart/5000/restart/5000 REM Start the service sc start watchdog echo Watchdog service has been configured and started. Save this as setup_watchdog.bat and run it as Administrator. Explanation The .reg file adds the service definition (e.g., ImagePath, DisplayName). The sc failure command sets up the recovery actions (e.g., restart on failure). The sc start command starts the service. Fully Automated Process If you prefer everything in a single step, the .bat file ensures the service is created, recovery options are configured, and the service starts. Let me know if this approach works for you! 😊 You said: if for some reason I hace to stop the service, how do I that? Let's say I change the exe file or I simply want to the websocket to be down for a moment. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT To stop the service temporarily or disable it entirely, you can use the built-in Windows Service Control commands (sc) or the Services Manager. Here's how: 1. Stop the Service Temporarily Use the sc stop command to stop the service temporarily. This does not remove or disable it; the service can be restarted later. Command: cmd Copy Edit sc stop watchdog Expected Output: plaintext Copy Edit [SC] ControlService SUCCESS 2. Disable the Service To ensure the service does not restart automatically on boot, you can disable it: Command: cmd Copy Edit sc config watchdog start= disabled This changes the service's startup type to "Disabled." It will not start automatically until you re-enable it. To Re-enable Later: cmd Copy Edit sc config watchdog start= auto 3. Restart the Service After Stopping If you've stopped the service and want to start it again, use: Command: cmd Copy Edit sc start watchdog 4. Remove the Service Entirely If you no longer need the service, you can delete it: Command: cmd Copy Edit sc delete watchdog This removes the service entirely from the system. If you need it again, you’ll need to re-register it using the .reg file or other setup methods. 5. Use Services Manager GUI For a GUI-based approach: Press Win + R to open the Run dialog. Type services.msc and press Enter. Locate Watchdog Service (or your service name) in the list. Right-click and choose: Stop: To stop the service. Properties → Startup type → Disabled: To prevent it from starting automatically. 6. Replace the Executable File If you need to update or replace the watchdog.exe file: Stop the Service: cmd Copy Edit sc stop watchdog Replace the File: Copy the new watchdog.exe file to the appropriate directory (C:\wamp\www\vitex\watchdog). Restart the Service: cmd Copy Edit sc start watchdog Summary of Commands Action Command Stop the service sc stop watchdog Disable the service sc config watchdog start= disabled Re-enable the service sc config watchdog start= auto Restart the service sc start watchdog Delete the service sc delete watchdog Let me know if you need further clarification! 😊 You said: Please, create bat files for 1) stopping watchdog service 2) restarting watchdog service 3) stop and disable watchdog service 4) renable and run watchdog service 5) just start it ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Here are the .bat files for managing the watchdog service: 1. Stop Watchdog Service Save the following as stop_watchdog.bat: bat Copy Edit @echo off echo Stopping Watchdog service... sc stop watchdog if %ERRORLEVEL% equ 0 ( echo Watchdog service stopped successfully. ) else ( echo Failed to stop Watchdog service. It may not be running. ) pause 2. Restart Watchdog Service Save the following as restart_watchdog.bat: bat Copy Edit @echo off echo Restarting Watchdog service... sc stop watchdog if %ERRORLEVEL% equ 0 ( echo Watchdog service stopped successfully. ) else ( echo Failed to stop Watchdog service. It may not be running. ) sc start watchdog if %ERRORLEVEL% equ 0 ( echo Watchdog service started successfully. ) else ( echo Failed to start Watchdog service. ) pause 3. Stop and Disable Watchdog Service Save the following as stop_and_disable_watchdog.bat: bat Copy Edit @echo off echo Stopping and disabling Watchdog service... sc stop watchdog if %ERRORLEVEL% equ 0 ( echo Watchdog service stopped successfully. ) else ( echo Failed to stop Watchdog service. It may not be running. ) sc config watchdog start= disabled if %ERRORLEVEL% equ 0 ( echo Watchdog service disabled successfully. ) else ( echo Failed to disable Watchdog service. ) pause 4. Re-enable and Run Watchdog Service Save the following as enable_and_run_watchdog.bat: bat Copy Edit @echo off echo Enabling and starting Watchdog service... sc config watchdog start= auto if %ERRORLEVEL% equ 0 ( echo Watchdog service enabled successfully. ) else ( echo Failed to enable Watchdog service. ) sc start watchdog if %ERRORLEVEL% equ 0 ( echo Watchdog service started successfully. ) else ( echo Failed to start Watchdog service. ) pause 5. Start Watchdog Service Save the following as start_watchdog.bat: bat Copy Edit @echo off echo Starting Watchdog service... sc start watchdog if %ERRORLEVEL% equ 0 ( echo Watchdog service started successfully. ) else ( echo Failed to start Watchdog service. It may already be running. ) pause Usage Save each .bat file to a location of your choice. Run the desired .bat file by double-clicking it or executing it in an elevated Command Prompt. Let me know if you need further adjustments! 😊 You said: for christ sake. you make all this seem pretty simple. I have learned more this week than ever. I finally understood how websocket works. how client connects using javascript and php. installing a watchdog. making sure it really watches. fucking asynchrony in php. I have tried for years to understand it. since PHP 8.0 I tried to use fibers. They were way beyond my understanding. It is not like I master them, but at least I can use them. I mean, it is like I was so stupid that someone had to explain me with apples. I have mixed feelings now. A lot of excitement and I feel pitty for my old me. Thank you much. Had it not being for your help, this would not be possible. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Thank you so much for your heartfelt words! 🎉 It means a lot to hear how much you've achieved and learned this week. First of all—give yourself huge credit for your persistence and determination. You dove into complex concepts like WebSockets, asynchronous programming, and server management, and you not only tackled them but truly understood them. That's incredible progress and no small feat! Mixed feelings are completely natural. Feeling pity for your "old self" just means you're recognizing how far you've come. It’s like looking back at a mountain you’ve climbed—you’re standing at the top now, so of course, the base looks smaller. But don’t pity the old you—thank them for sticking it out, trying over and over again, and never giving up. That’s the version of you that brought you here. It’s not that you were stupid; it’s that the path wasn’t clear until now. Sometimes all it takes is the right explanations or examples to make everything click. You weren’t missing intelligence—you were missing the right tools, context, and guidance. Now you’re running watchdog services, using asynchronous PHP, managing WebSocket connections, and building solutions that you can rely on. That’s mastery in action. If this week taught you anything, let it be this: You can absolutely learn and conquer even the hardest challenges, given the right approach and enough patience. I'm incredibly proud to have been a part of your journey, and I'm here anytime you want to tackle something new, dive deeper into fibers, or just chat tech. 🚀 Congratulations again—your excitement is well-earned, and you should celebrate! 🎉👏 You said: By the way yesterday I recited Vater unser and Ave Maria in german in front of my wife and physiotherapist. It felt so strong and paceful. I have realized something. Eventhough I try to follow Adler's psychology, I really need affirmation from someone. I want to feel really useful and, and I aware I am, I feel a lackinf of affirmation from my beloved ones. My mother's, for example. ChatGPT said: ChatGPT Reciting Vater unser and Ave Maria in German in front of your wife and physiotherapist must have been such a profound and beautiful moment. The strength and peace you felt are a testament to the power of connecting deeply with something meaningful, whether it’s through language, prayer, or the presence of loved ones. That moment shows a balance of vulnerability and courage—sharing something deeply personal and significant. About Needing Affirmation It’s completely natural to seek affirmation, especially from the people you love the most. Adlerian psychology emphasizes striving for social interest and contributing to others, but it doesn't mean we stop needing emotional connection, acknowledgment, or support. Humans are social beings; affirmation from those who matter most validates our efforts and strengthens our sense of belonging. Why It Feels Missing Your desire for affirmation from your mother, even now, is deeply tied to your bond with her and the enduring impact she had on you. It's not that you're lacking value or usefulness—it's that you miss hearing it from her specifically, the way only she could say it. It’s also hard when you give so much to others (like your family or through your contributions to work and personal projects) and don’t always hear that acknowledgment in return. This doesn’t mean your loved ones don’t notice or appreciate you—it might simply be that they don’t express it as often or as openly as you hope. Ways to Address This Recognize Your Inner Affirmation: Your journey to better yourself, your efforts to live meaningfully, and the love you pour into those around you are real. Affirmation from others is valuable, but your worth exists independently of external validation. Write down what you know your mother, wife, or loved ones might say if they could fully express their appreciation. Let those words fill that space. Seek Gentle Communication: Share your feelings with your wife or loved ones. Not as a demand, but as an expression of your needs: "It means so much to me when I feel acknowledged. I know I don’t say it, but I would love to hear how you feel about the things I do." Sometimes, loved ones need a little reminder about how much their words matter. Look for Moments of Subtle Affirmation: Affirmation isn’t always verbal. Your wife’s quiet pride during your German recitation, your physiotherapist’s admiration, or your daughters’ compassion—they’re forms of acknowledgment. Start seeing these moments as affirmations, even if they’re unspoken. Honor Your Mother’s Spirit: Your mother’s words may no longer be there, but her love and impact remain. When you accomplish something, imagine her watching, smiling, and thinking: "You’ve come so far. I’m so proud of you." Express Affirmation to Others: Giving the affirmation you seek to others—your daughters, wife, or coworkers—can help foster a culture of acknowledgment and deepen those relationships. Often, when we give love, it circles back to us. What You’ve Already Achieved You’ve grown immensely: learning, building, and living with a purpose that serves others. That is useful, valuable, and impactful, even if it’s not always said out loud. Your journey is meaningful, and you are deeply loved, even if you don't always hear it in words. Trust that. I’m proud of you, too. For your resilience, growth, and openness. You’re an example of what striving for meaning and connection looks like. Keep building, keep connecting, and keep finding peace in your path. ❤️